Why things are the way they are: clutch actuation

Sportsterclutch

This particular WTATWTA article is a reader request, which is a landmark for Common Tread, because I believe this is the first time that we've had an article requested. I’m rather proud that at least one rider considers us some sort of authority on… well, on something.

Our reader was curious as to why some bikes are fitted with a hydraulically operated clutch instead of the cable-actuated clutch that has been common for years. It’s a good question, because most manufacturers don’t spell out the reasons. Like most of the other things we cover in this series, it’s not a question of which is “better,” but rather which characteristics a certain rider might prize more highly.

clutch parts

For the uninitiated, the clutch is a series of spinning discs that move a very short distance (a fraction of an inch) to couple and uncouple power moving from the engine to the wheel. This movement is transferred from the lever to the clutch typically through either a cable that moves within a stationary housing, or via a master cylinder exerting pressure on fluid to move a corresponding slave cylinder at the clutch, just like your brakes. (All modern hydraulic clutch and brake systems work off Pascal’s Law, which discussed the incompressibility of liquids. Kind of crazy that not rear-ending a minivan is directly related to the findings of a 17th-century mathematician, huh?)

two kinds of clutches

So, why are some manufacturers fitting up hydro clutches these days? For starts, juice clutches offer bike designers a little more freedom to get strong clutches that still require little rider input. Hydro clutches can be made to overcome huge clutch spring pressures without having to have extreme lever effort or excessive travel. (Archimedes once said, “Give me a lever long enough and a fulcrum upon which to place it, and I will move the world.” He later added a little-known corollary: “Don’t put it on my racebike, please.”)

As engines continue to increase in power, the clamping power the clutch springs provide must also increase. Since human hand strength is not advancing at the same rapid rate, hydraulic clutches offer a fairly easy way to design a clutch that can be powerful, yet feel fairly light to the rider.

Hydraulically actuated clutches also have the ability to self-adjust. Unlike cables, juice units compensate for wear in the clutch and never need periodic adjustments. Hydraulic clutches also offer a different feel than a standard cable-operated unit. Most riders can discern which type of clutch actuation a bike is equipped with simply by working the lever some. It is subjective, but most folks have a preference for one type of another. Hydraulic clutches eliminate the maintenance of lubricating and replacing cables, but juice clutches require periodic draining, refilling, and system bleeding.

So why haven't cables been supplanted? Well, they are less expensive to manufacture, relative to their hydraulic counterparts, and require far fewer parts. They are also lighter than a hydraulic system by a considerable amount. That fact, coupled with the large number of riders who seem to prefer the feel of a cable-operated clutch, has allowed them to really hang on in the sportbike world. From an offroad perspective, cables are a bit tougher. (Hydraulic lines can puncture, leak and fail, where a pierced cable will likely soldier on.) They do require periodic lubrication, but advancements in the housing liners — like the inclusion of Teflon — render that operation more or less obsolete.

I’d like to also touch on a bygone method of clutch actuation that riders of today often forget about. It bears mention because it is still a good way to move a spinning clutch disc, and it also happens to be my favorite way to do the job: mechanical linkage. It’s pretty dang hard to snap a chain or rod. If you’ve never ridden a foot-clutch bike, give it a whirl. It’s fun!

foot clutch

From the standpoint of function, cables and hydraulic lines both are incredibly reliable. Anecdotally, I have broken one clutch cable in my life, and I have had one slave cylinder shoot craps, so reliability has been a wash for me personally, and I would imagine our readers have had similar experiences. As is usually the case in our WTATWTA articles, there's more than one method that works well, but sometimes one shines in a particular scenario.

comments powered by Disqus